Link Details

Link 69646 thumbnail
User 259727 avatar

By dustinbrewer
via dustinbrewer.com
Published: Mar 07 2008 / 08:23

It looks like IE8 is going down the same broken path that Internet Explorer 6 took. They are making up markup and not adhering to web standards at all. They didn't even really pass the acid2 test like they told us.
  • 11
  • 24
  • 1693
  • 608

Comments

Add your comment
User 247528 avatar

dengar007 replied ago:

5 votes Vote down Vote up Reply

IE has some work but it is still beta ... this article jumps to a lot of conclusions...

User 224257 avatar

wekempf replied ago:

3 votes Vote down Vote up Reply

That was the most biased load of tripe I've ever read. IE8 doesn't pass Acid2? Really? Proof? I've seen it pass with my own eyes. I thought maybe you were referring to the fact that it fails one test in Acid2 when the test is hosted on a site other than the official site, which the IE8 team officially blogged about and explained. If it's a security issue, I'm glad they fail there. Doesn't change the fact that they pass the REAL Acid2 test.

They've added things? Oh no! They're not standards compliant! What B.S. I'm willing to bet every browser has extensions. That doesn't effect standards compliance at all. In fact, that's how standards progress. Microsoft has said they're submitting such changes to the standards committee for *possible* inclusion.

It's slower than even IE6! Uhmmm... it's a developer beta. I would have been beyond floored if this were not the case.

There's an opt-out meta tag! Oh no! Jeez. It's a risky enough move for them to make things standard by default. Not including the tag would be the absolute worst thing they could have done. The fact that you're going to make the lame attempt to beat up on them about that says your a moron. Sorry, don't like name calling, but there's not much else to say at this point. You either don't have the capacity to reason, or you have a political agenda and are purposely attempting to twist facts, and expect your readership to be to stupid to get that.

User 204329 avatar

ddelponte replied ago:

-5 votes [show comment] Vote down Vote up Reply
User 224257 avatar

wekempf replied ago:

0 votes Vote down Vote up Reply

Yes, that's exactly what I said *rolls eyes*. Can we stick to facts, instead of playing politics?

User 247528 avatar

dengar007 replied ago:

4 votes Vote down Vote up Reply

It's a controversial topic / title -- it drives site traffic. Hopefully, that is the explanation for this lack of research.

User 217374 avatar

senfo replied ago:

3 votes Vote down Vote up Reply

IE8 does pass the ACID 2 test. Kind of. The reason that the latest beta does not pass is because of cross site scripting prevention.

Read this article:

http://blogs.msdn.com/ie/archive/2008/03/05/why-isn-t-ie8-passing-acid2.aspx

User 209830 avatar

David Paul replied ago:

2 votes Vote down Vote up Reply

i think it was right of them to stop cross-site ActiveX controls

Add your comment


Html tags not supported. Reply is editable for 5 minutes. Use [code lang="java|ruby|sql|css|xml"][/code] to post code snippets.